Palm Beach Members Only Shows That Money Can’t Buy Fulfillment

Netflix’s new reality show Palm Beach: Members Only promises glitz, glamour, and the inside scoop on one of America’s wealthiest enclaves, but what lands on screen is a much bleaker spectacle. Think designer labels, perfectly curated brunches, and hair so high it defies gravity… all masking a hunger for validation that no amount of money can satisfy.

From the very first episode, the show feels less like modern reality TV and more like a dusty time capsule from a country club’s golden era. The cast, Rosalyn Yellin, Hilary Musser, Ro-mina Ustayev, Maria Cozamanis, and Taja Abitbol—are presented as women “living the dream” in Palm Beach. But if this is the dream, someone clearly forgot to wake them up.

Old Money vs. New Money: The Palm Beach Game

Palm Beach is not just a place, it’s a hierarchy. For over a century, it has been a playground for the elite: billionaires, hedge fund royalty, and political powerhouses. Legacy matters more than personality, and invitations are currency.

Here, private clubs, charity galas, and curated guest lists are the backbone of social life. But as the show painfully illustrates, these events are less about enjoyment and more about performing status. Dress right, smile at the right people, attend the right luncheons, and maybe—just maybe—you’ll be “seen” by someone who matters.

The irony is that the events themselves are often painfully dull, yet treated like Olympic trials for social supremacy. Netflix viewers on X and Instagram were quick to point this out, tweeting lines like:

“Palm Beach: Members Only is exhausting. Watching people elbow for attention in a club nobody outside Palm Beach cares about is tragic and hilarious at the same time.”

The Cast and Their Social Battles

Rosalyn Yellin stands out as the self-appointed finishing school headmistress of Palm Beach social etiquette. She wields her influence with ruthless efficiency, policing the newcomers on everything from cleavage-to-knee ratios to charity attendance. Ro-mina Ustayev, the show’s “outsider,” quickly becomes the target, forced to shrink and reshape herself to fit an invisible hierarchy.

Meanwhile, Maria Cozamanis, presented as the Palm Beach DJ, brings chaos to every scene. Her emotional volatility turns dinners into therapy sessions nobody asked for, making the show feel both staged and deeply uncomfortable.

The social dynamics mirror high school cliques on steroids: the new girl must be corrected, the popular ones dictate taste and behavior, and cruelty is framed as mentorship. For many viewers, it’s hard not to feel sympathy for those being excluded. Social media users have been particularly vocal:

“Watching Ustayev try to fit in is genuinely sad. Rich people problems, but also very relatable if you’ve ever been the outsider,” tweeted one viewer.

The Real Drama? Money Can’t Buy Meaning

What’s striking about Members Only is what it doesn’t show. There are few husbands, barely any children, and almost no authentic personal lives. Instead, the camera lingers on women bending themselves into emotional origami for fleeting social approval.

The show inadvertently asks a critical question: what is the point of all this effort? To say you once stood next to someone famous? To be included in a club that offers little beyond visibility? As one critic tweeted:

“Money can buy access, but it can’t buy depth. Palm Beach Members Only proves that painfully.”

Even the opulent setting, the beaches, the architecture, the ocean views, is mostly wasted. The show is so preoccupied with its status games that it forgets the actual backdrop is worth watching.

Verdict: Glittering, But Hollow

Palm Beach: Members Only is less aspirational than cautionary. Watching wealthy women chase social validation at the expense of authenticity is exhausting and, at times, sad. While it may satisfy a craving for celebrity gossip, it’s repetitive, tedious, and emotionally draining, making viewers question the real value of status, wealth, and social climbing.

Rating: ★★☆☆☆ – glamorous on the surface, but a hollow spectacle underneath.

Source: IOL

Featured Image: X{@decider}