Tyla faces backlash over silence on East Rand femicides

by Rhaees Hanslo

The brutal reality of South Africa’s gender-based violence crisis has once again gripped the nation, sparking widespread mourning, public fury, and intense social commentary.

From shocking local headlines, such as Grammy winner Tyla’s sister, Sydney Seethal, recounting a terrifying physical robbery ordeal in Gauteng, to systemic violence on the streets, safety remains a daily trauma for South African women.

Also see: Tyla’s sister recounts terrifying robbery ordeal in South Africa

As communities grapple with fear and demand swift structural justice, the conversation has expanded from government inaction to the complex, demanding expectations placed on global figures during moments of national tragedy. 

A region traumatised by systemic violence

The horrific discovery of nine women’s bodies across Ekurhuleni over the past two months, including the latest victim found dumped near a construction site in Dawn Park, has plunged Gauteng into a state of shock, grief, and heightened panic.

With victims found partially clothed, showing signs of severe physical trauma, and abandoned in open velds, residents and advocacy groups like Women For Change are sounding the alarm over what many fear is the work of a serial killer targeting women.

The escalating crisis has triggered nationwide protests and memorial runs, igniting urgent calls for police intervention, government accountability, and a decisive stand against South Africa’s relentless gender-based violence (GBV) pandemic.

The call for global celebrity accountability

Amidst this heavy atmosphere of national mourning, public scrutiny has unexpectedly turned toward Grammy-winning pop star Tyla.

Raised on the East Rand in Edleen, Kempton Park, just kilometres from where several of the bodies were discovered, the singer drew sharp online criticism for continuing her routine promotional posts for new music rather than acknowledging the tragedy unfolding in her home region.

Frustrated commentators on social media questioned why a global figure with immense reach remained quiet while local influencers and activists used their platforms to amplify calls for justice. Critics further cited her past industry ties, arguing that high-profile South African artists operating on international stages carry a moral obligation to highlight the brutal realities facing women back home.

Also see: Police offer R400,000 reward to help solve Ekurhuleni women’s deaths

A misdirected outrage or moral responsibility?

However, the backlash against Tyla has sparked an equally fierce debate surrounding celebrity culture and public expectations. Defenders of the singer quickly pointed out that directing anger toward a pop artist diverts critical focus away from political and law enforcement failures.

Critics of the online mob argued that holding an artist responsible for addressing systemic violent crime is unreasonable, asserting that public rage belongs squarely at the feet of government leadership and the South African Police Service (SAPS), who have repeatedly failed to secure the safety of women.

This tension highlights a recurring dilemma in contemporary culture: the fine line between demanding public solidarity from global figures and scapegoating individuals for deep-seated state inaction.

Reclaiming focus on systemic justice

Ultimately, the online debate surrounding celebrity silence underscores a much deeper, pervasive frustration across South Africa: a society exhausted by perpetual violence and desperate to be heard.

While high-profile voices can undeniably elevate social movements, relying on pop cultural figures to headline human rights crises risks distracting from the core issue.

True progress will not come from social media posts or online call-outs, but from demanding tangible institutional reform, swift justice from law enforcement, and decisive state action to protect the lives of South African women.

Also see: East Rand killings continue: South Africans respond as 9th body found

Be the first to know – Join our WhatsApp channel for content worth tapping into. Click here to join!